Imagine you have cancer, schizophrenia or a spinal injury, and you rely on Medicaid, America's public health insurance for people on low incomes. From January 2027, many adults on Medicaid must log 80 hours a month of work, study or volunteering to keep their cover. You should be exempt: Congress said so. Then a federal agency added a hurdle: prove that your condition also significantly impairs your ability to meet the work rules.
On 29 October 2026, a federal judge in Boston struck that hurdle down. This article examines the legal definition of "medically frail", and why a definition written by lawmakers cannot be quietly rewritten by the officials who administer it.
A rule, a lawsuit and a judgment
The case, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, was brought by 25 states and the District of Columbia against the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the federal agency that oversees Medicaid, and its administrator, Dr Mehmet Oz. The states sued on 29 June over an interim final rule that CMS published on 3 June. Such rules take effect before public comments are considered.
Judge Richard Stearns refused to pause the rule in July. On 29 October, however, he granted the states summary judgment, a ruling on the legal arguments without a full trial. CMS's extra test, he held, was "beyond the powers of CMS (ultra vires) and thus contrary to law". Ultra vires means acting outside one's legal authority.
He struck the offending words from the rule, barred their enforcement and gave the plaintiff states six months' grace on frailty checks. But he upheld a rule limiting states to the past 12 months of claims data when verifying frailty, and a cap on how often people can simply declare themselves frail. The work requirements still begin on 1 January 2027.
What Congress wrote
The 2025 law exempts anyone "who is medically frail or otherwise has special medical needs (as defined by the Secretary), including" five groups: people who are blind or disabled; people with a substance use disorder; people with a disabling mental disorder; people whose physical, intellectual or developmental disability significantly impairs one or more activities of daily living; and people with a serious or complex medical condition. The Secretary here is the US Secretary of Health and Human Services.
The term was not new. Medicaid's rules on alternative benefit plans, a type of coverage package, already required each state's definition of medically frail to "at least include" a very similar list, under 42 CFR 440.315(f). Congress used "existing terminology", the University of Missouri public policy professor Jake Haselswerdt told Newsweek in July, and gave no sign it meant something new.
Judge Stearns treated "including" as doing real work. Drawing on case law that reads the word as introducing examples, he held that Congress meant the five groups to "set a definitional floor". The Secretary can build on that floor, but cannot dig beneath it.
Floor or hurdle?
CMS's rule covered only people in those groups whose condition "significantly impairs the individual's ability to comply with the community engagement requirement", the law's formal name for the work rules. In its explanation, CMS argued the term "connotes diminished functional capacity", and that a diagnosis alone "would risk sweeping in" people who could still meet the requirement.
The government relied on the words "as defined by the Secretary". "The delegation, not the word 'including,' is the key feature," its lawyers wrote in a reply brief filed in October. Being told to include broad categories, they argued, is not a command to include everyone who might fit them.
"Congress made clear that people with serious medical conditions should not lose coverage," said Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, who co-led the challenge, when the states sued. Eleven medical bodies, including the American Medical Association, warned the court that the test would make doctors judges of work capacity, a task most are not trained for.
The judge sided with the text. Congress wrote a functional limit into one category only, disability affecting daily activities, showing it "knew how to qualify classifications and did so where it wished". This is the job the Supreme Court, in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), gave courts: "fixing the boundaries" of power Congress delegates.
Why should anyone outside Medicaid care? Because a statutory definition is a promise. When Congress names who is protected, people plan their lives around that list and states build systems to honour it. An agency may fill gaps; it may not quietly redraw the edges.
Judge Stearns did not condemn work requirements, and he upheld much of CMS's rule. His point was narrower: if "medically frail" is to mean less, Congress must say so. CMS declined to comment, citing pending litigation, and could still appeal. For now, the definition stands as Congress wrote it: a floor, not a hurdle.
